Dr. Zakir Naik and His Hosts
The esteemed and popular Islamic scholar Dr. Zakir Naik is currently visiting Pakistan. However, it remains unclear who invited him to the country. Was it the Government of Pakistan, a religious organization, or some other institution? Speculations abound, but it is my belief that the current government did not invite him out of enthusiasm or eagerness, given its different policies.
It seems unlikely that the current rulers, who have a different stance on global issues, would invite an internationally renowned Islamic preacher who openly condemns Israel. If the government had indeed invited him, a senior official such as the Minister of Religious Affairs would have been present to receive him at the airport. Instead, the advisor on youth affairs was sent, signaling a low-key reception. Even at the Prime Minister’s House, the ministers greeted him with indifference. This lack of enthusiasm suggests that the government extended the invitation reluctantly, and this was evident at the reception held at the Governor House in Karachi.
Dr. Naik is accustomed to addressing massive audiences and delivering lectures on religious topics. Normally, only his chair is placed on stage, as he speaks alone. However, in Karachi, the event was turned into a public gathering, with others seated on stage alongside him, and they were also handed the microphone to engage him in unnecessary heated discussions. This deviation from the norm was noticed across the country.
It is clear that Dr. Naik’s hosts should have organized the program themselves and ensured that the event remained focused on his lecture, not a debate, with only him on stage. Dr. Naik may have been disappointed upon seeing the situation in Pakistan, where sectarianism is rampant. In societies where ignorance prevails, sectarianism thrives. Religious parties have become sectarian organizations, engaging in power politics rather than upholding true ideological values.
I, personally, have rejected sectarianism since my youth. From the first day of my service, whenever asked to declare my sect, I’ve always written “Muslim.” The Prophet ﷺ and Allah have named us Muslims, and we are forbidden from dividing ourselves into sects.
Dr. Naik’s visit to Pakistan should have been a source of pride, but before his arrival, opponents—both sectarian and those hostile to religion—had already begun criticizing his visit. Some even expressed concerns, claiming that “his presence could upset the balance between different sects in the country.”
These critics, who often ridicule ordinary scholars for their lack of knowledge, are now disturbed by the arrival of a well-read Islamic preacher. They find it unsettling that someone who understands Christianity, Judaism, and Hinduism better than their own religious leaders has a global influence. Such people are constantly seeking faults in Dr. Naik, circling around him with magnifying glasses, hoping to find something to criticize.
Yes, Dr. Naik’s command of Urdu may not be strong, and his speeches may lack the eloquence of other great speakers. Sometimes, he struggles to find the right words, especially when answering complex religious questions. But it is his sincerity, strong faith, and purity of character that Allah has blessed him with, giving his words a profound impact that even surpasses the fluency of the most eloquent speakers.
Information suggests that Dr. Naik leads a simple and ascetic life, unlike many of our religious leaders. He could easily earn millions through social media, but he doesn’t take a single penny and has devoted his life entirely to serving his Creator. This is his destiny. He is focused on guiding people towards Allah, while some narrow-minded individuals are busy finding flaws in him.
Respected Dr. Naik, keep in mind that this is not the Pakistan of the 1980s. The Pakistan you see today has lost its ideological direction. While there may be few who oppose you, the liberals and secularists dominate both mainstream and social media. I urge you to get a thorough briefing on the political, social, and religious conditions of the country, particularly on the rising sectarianism and the youth’s growing distance from religion.
Your expertise in comparative religion is well known, but I suggest you also study the works of local scholars on issues that are relevant to modern-day Muslims and young minds. If reading Urdu is difficult, listen to audio recordings, and then craft your responses. This will make your arguments more robust and persuasive. As a preacher, control your emotions and anger, and aim to persuade rather than outwit the questioner—except, of course, those who ask out of mischief.
I also appeal to Dr. Naik’s hosts to acknowledge his services to Islam by honoring him with a prestigious award, much like other Islamic countries have done. This award should surpass even the one given to a certain Dubai watch merchant.
